Ethiopia: The Election Code of Conduct Plagiarized – Did Not Need Negotiation
The much-talked about, but never analyzed, Ethiopia’s 2010 Election Code of Conduct is a work of plagiarism, a direct line-by-line and word-by-word translation into Amharic of the English-language “sample” document originally authored by the Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (IDEA). Even though the translation was mentioned in news stories distributed by TPLF (the ruling party), the extent of the “translation” was never disclosed. Four political parties: the ruling party, AEUP and two others referred by many as “moles of the ruling party in the opposition” have signed the Electoral Code of Conduct after weeks of “negotiations.” As it stands now, the Code of Conduct seems to have been intended to hoodwink the international donor community.
|
VIDEO – Medrek Leadership: Press Conference on the “Translation” Project of the Code of Conduct |
The major opposition coalition, Medrek – the Forum for Democratic Dialogue, had not partaken in the document “translation” efforts of the other four parties. According to Medrek, “translating” an English-language document into Amharic does not count as a “negotiation” with the ruling party, that abuses government and state power to promote party agendas. It is puzzling to many what part of the “translation” project needed a “negotiation” among the other four political parties – the appropriate choice of an Amharic word for the English-language equivalent? Or whether the verb should be past tense or present?
The contributions of AEUP and EDP to the Code of Conduct document were said to be their inputs about electoral learning from Ghana and South Africa. Well, the IDEA English-language document clearly states that learning from Ghana and South Africa have been taken into consideration (see the Annex of the document given below). From the list of countries in the Annex, Ghana and South Africa were chosen by TPLF propagandists for they’re popularly known to hold democratic elections. Does copying a document from elsewhere make the election in Ethiopia fair and free? It’s action that counts; otherwise, the “document” that the law is written in becomes a piece of paper.
The “negotiation” should be about overhauling the electoral system; it should be about making the Election Board accountable to the public, not TPLF; it should be about stopping the intimidation of opposition members by TPLF; it should be about stopping TPLF’s use of food aid to buy votes and support; it should be about freeing all political prisoners; it should be about allowing the state-owned media to be used fairly by all political parties and not making it a TPLF monopoly, and so on.
Here are the English-language document from IDEA and the Amharic translation from the ruling party – both PDF files:
- Code of Conduct for Political Parties (IDEA)
- Electoral Code of Conduct – Ethiopia
»» BACK TO MAIN PAGE
1 Comment »
RSS feed for comments on this post
Write Your Comment Below.
RULES FOR COMMENTING:
Gadaa.com values your inputs, and to maintain a positive environment of discussion, the following rules will be enforced for comments. When you click SUBMIT COMMENT below, you are agreeing to abide by the following rules.
1. Comments are moderated. Your comment appears below after it has been approved by a Gadaa.com Admin.
2. If you use different names to post comments, we will delete all of your comments.
3. Apply common-sense respect and courtesy.
4. By submitting your comments, you take all the responsibility, legal or otherwise, for your comments.
5. Comments are naturally short. Long comments may not be approved.
6. Frequent offenders of the above rules will lose future posting privileges.
Due to a large number of spam comments, those who comment will now need to register/log-in before commenting. System is configured to ban users with multiple usernames.
You must be logged in to post a comment or create an account.


Jalatama said,
November 17, 2009 @ 11:28 pm
Most things in Ethiopia are either cut and paste or it is proposed by Western governments and international organizations like IMF, WB and the like, without even taking into consideration the domestic realities.